5x07 "The Life and Death of Jeremy Bentham" Review
"The Life and Death of Jeremy Bentham" was another fantastic episode of LOST's fifth season. John Locke has had one of the most interesting and important story arcs of the entire show.
The episode begins inside a presumed DHARMA station, with Caesar, who is searching through various DHARMA maps and supplies. Ilana tells Caesar that they found a man on the beach, who nobody remembers from the plane.
That man is none other than John Locke - who we last saw dead in a coffin. Locke tells Ilana that he remembers dying. We flashback to the end of "This Place Is Death", when Locke turns the frozen wheel to move the Island. Locke ends up in the middle of the Tunisia desert, just like Ben from "The Shape of Things To Come". He is severely wounded from injuring his leg back at the Orchid. There is a camera watching Locke, and at night, a car arrives, and takes Locke to a hospital. While the doctors are mending Locke's leg, we get a glimpse of Matthew Abaddon. Abaddon was the mysterious man who appeared as an orderly after Locke was in a wheelchair, and told him to go on the walkabout, which eventually led him to the Island. Abaddon also was in charge of the freighter's science team, and he appointed Naomi Dorrit to look after the group of four (Daniel Faraday the physicist, Charlotte Lewis the antropologist, Miles Straume the spiritualist, and Frank Lapidus the pilot). In "The Beginning of the End", we also saw Abaddon visit Hurley at Santa Rosa, asking him the all-important question: "Are they still alive?"
The episode begins inside a presumed DHARMA station, with Caesar, who is searching through various DHARMA maps and supplies. Ilana tells Caesar that they found a man on the beach, who nobody remembers from the plane.
That man is none other than John Locke - who we last saw dead in a coffin. Locke tells Ilana that he remembers dying. We flashback to the end of "This Place Is Death", when Locke turns the frozen wheel to move the Island. Locke ends up in the middle of the Tunisia desert, just like Ben from "The Shape of Things To Come". He is severely wounded from injuring his leg back at the Orchid. There is a camera watching Locke, and at night, a car arrives, and takes Locke to a hospital. While the doctors are mending Locke's leg, we get a glimpse of Matthew Abaddon. Abaddon was the mysterious man who appeared as an orderly after Locke was in a wheelchair, and told him to go on the walkabout, which eventually led him to the Island. Abaddon also was in charge of the freighter's science team, and he appointed Naomi Dorrit to look after the group of four (Daniel Faraday the physicist, Charlotte Lewis the antropologist, Miles Straume the spiritualist, and Frank Lapidus the pilot). In "The Beginning of the End", we also saw Abaddon visit Hurley at Santa Rosa, asking him the all-important question: "Are they still alive?"
When Locke wakes up, Widmore talks to him, explaining that he was once the leader of the Others, but was exiles because of Ben. Locke explains that he left the Island willingly, and Widmore knows it's so that he can bring them back.
Widmore provides Locke with all the information on the Oceanic Six, and leaves Locke with Matthew Abaddon. They first travel to Santo Domingo, where Sayid is building a house. Sayid is adament about staying off-Island. Locke then goes to see Walt, who says that he's been having dreams about him. Locke doesn't ask Walt to come back, because "he's been through enough". Kate is also adament about staying, and says that the only reason Locke wants to stay is because he's never been in love.
Locke goes to visit Helen Norwood, who died of a brain disease. After this, Abaddon is shot dead by Ben, and Locke gets in a car accident. He is taken to a hospital, and sees Jack. Locke says it's fate that they go back, but Jack says he's a lonely old man who survived a plane crash.
Locke attempts to hang himself, but is stopped by Ben, who says Locke still has work to do. Shortly after Locke mentions that Jin is still alive, Ben strangles him to death.
This is one of the best episodes of the entire series in my opinion. Locke has such an intriguing story arc, and is definitely important to the overall story. This episode raises many questions: What war is Widmore referring to? Why did Ben kill Locke? Who is good, Widmore (the man who sent a team to torch the Island) or Ben (the man who attempted to kill Locke because he could see Jacob)? I think that Ben has his own agenda; to be the leader of the Others, and Jacob.
I think that the 'war' will eventually be between Widmore and Ben, since they both seem to want to be in control of the Island. I thought this was a fantastic episode. Locke has been vigorously trying to convince them to come back, but he was met with bitter resistance from Sayid, Kate, and Jack. After his death though, we all know that they change their minds.
This episode was a fantastic way to show Locke's mission off the Island, and also included one of the most shocking moments of the series (Ben killed Locke!). The acting was also incredible in this episode, with a great performance from Terry O'Quinn (John Locke). I was surprised to see Abaddon die so soon - he seemed to be the bearer of great mystery to me. Overall, this was a fantastic episode.
Widmore provides Locke with all the information on the Oceanic Six, and leaves Locke with Matthew Abaddon. They first travel to Santo Domingo, where Sayid is building a house. Sayid is adament about staying off-Island. Locke then goes to see Walt, who says that he's been having dreams about him. Locke doesn't ask Walt to come back, because "he's been through enough". Kate is also adament about staying, and says that the only reason Locke wants to stay is because he's never been in love.
Locke goes to visit Helen Norwood, who died of a brain disease. After this, Abaddon is shot dead by Ben, and Locke gets in a car accident. He is taken to a hospital, and sees Jack. Locke says it's fate that they go back, but Jack says he's a lonely old man who survived a plane crash.
Locke attempts to hang himself, but is stopped by Ben, who says Locke still has work to do. Shortly after Locke mentions that Jin is still alive, Ben strangles him to death.
This is one of the best episodes of the entire series in my opinion. Locke has such an intriguing story arc, and is definitely important to the overall story. This episode raises many questions: What war is Widmore referring to? Why did Ben kill Locke? Who is good, Widmore (the man who sent a team to torch the Island) or Ben (the man who attempted to kill Locke because he could see Jacob)? I think that Ben has his own agenda; to be the leader of the Others, and Jacob.
I think that the 'war' will eventually be between Widmore and Ben, since they both seem to want to be in control of the Island. I thought this was a fantastic episode. Locke has been vigorously trying to convince them to come back, but he was met with bitter resistance from Sayid, Kate, and Jack. After his death though, we all know that they change their minds.
This episode was a fantastic way to show Locke's mission off the Island, and also included one of the most shocking moments of the series (Ben killed Locke!). The acting was also incredible in this episode, with a great performance from Terry O'Quinn (John Locke). I was surprised to see Abaddon die so soon - he seemed to be the bearer of great mystery to me. Overall, this was a fantastic episode.




39 comments:
Overall, this was a terrible review. I'm sorry, but an episode review should be much more than plot summary, and stating that it is a "fantastic episode." You did not leave much of your own opinion about the episode yourself either.
"Who is good, Widmore or Ben?"
There's a false dichotomy if I ever saw one...hehehe
hey tomin, everyone's a critic. why don't you leave something substantive if you've got such a problem?
yeah. thought so.
Ben killed John Locke because he mentioned that he knows Eloise. I guess Ben was afraid that both will meet and therefore killed John immediately. Maybe Ben thought, they wouldn't need him anymore, if both will meet.
^"Both" who or what will meet?^ I think Ben killed Locke after he mentioned Ellie because a) he realized Locke knew enough now to threaten Ben's position as leader (Not of the Others, but of the O6-ers. Information is currency in this show, after all.) or b) he was jealous of John, and didn't want him to be Ellie's new pet. Ben has demonstrated time and time again how jealous he gets, and he's definitely killed to get what he covets before.
Lol CTS - Locke can do no wrong for you.
The war is between us - I can't stand Locke and his sanctimonious attitude to everything Island-related.
"Shortly after Locke mentions that Jin is still alive, Ben strangles him to death."
No No No No No
Must be changed to :
Shortly after Ben hears John mention the name, Eloise Hawking does he kill John.
tominkozhimala is right. This 'review' is not a review, but a half-baked attempt at a plot summary, minus many important details.
Well guys, I've been switching writers these last few weeks because:
a) I feel like just my style is bad and people might prefer different peoples' reviews.
b) I can't do review blogs til about 12-20 hours after the episode airs, which in LOST world is a long amount of radio silence
c) It's nice to take the work load off with alternate bloggers
5x06 was ILostMyKeys, 5x07 was CTS. Next week will probably be Santa - whose style you will no doubt prefer (he's awesome and our top Lostpedia wiki editor). After that, I'll be returning so the reviews will resemble 5x01-5x05 in style. If that's your preference, good times - but to be honest I think some people prefer reviews like I do them, whilst others do prefer more recappy reviews.
I didn't hate this review or anything, but I do definitely prefer a healthy dose of analysis with my reviews. A recap is fine if that's what you're going for, but I think most people who come to check out the Lostpedia blog already saw the episode and are looking for some kind of insight or revelations about things they might not have picked up on, rather than just a blow-by-blow recap of the episode. I already got the who, what, when, and where. I want the why!
So what does one have to do to become one of these episode bloggers, anyhow?
Yeah this was an 'okay' recap, stressing that word loosely. There were some incorrect lines, like the already mentioned Eloise Hawking and the strangling that followed. Overall, not a review. But hey everyone needs a break! We all have our separate lives too. :) Hope the next ones are better.
Sorry to whoever wrote this one, add some personal insight, or that angle that multiple writers can express, next time. You'll get better at it.
I dislike recaps when they are labled as reviews but c'mon guys, nobody is forcing you to read 'em! Get over it and head on over to ew.com or scour the net for other FAN reviews!
Anyhoo I for one was shocked to see Abaddon get plugged in the manner that he did. I remember thinking a couple weeks back if he would ever return. Sigh, careful what you wish for... All in all I enjoyed all the loose threds this episode tied up and the others it created.
For those of you who are interested in the "numbers": Birthday on Jeremy Benthem's passport 15 Feb '48. 4,8 and 15 are part of the numerical sequence. Widmore's "direct dial" is 2,3 or 23 another part of 4,8,15,16,23,42.
Nickb123: I for one definitely prefer your reviews to the others I've seen so far. But I hope that isn't taken as too negative toward the others, juts a preference. I do, however, think that a review that comes as quickly as this one did risks containing errors and missing important details. This one had some misses. I would like reviewers to take the time to watch the episode a couple of times and take their time making the review as good as they can.
Little bit off-topic: Anyone know why lostpedia hasn't updated today?
I would love to hear what all of you think about whether there is a relationship between Abaddon and Walt. I used to personally think that maybe Abaddon was a grown-up version of Walt who can appear in different places and time, but obviously in this epsiode they appear at the same time so this may be less likely (still possible with time travel???). These two are the only characters who refer to John as "Mr. Locke". This may seem small, but the writers are very intentional about dialogue. Is Abaddon another relative of Michael's? Who knows... but I like the mystery that surrounds him and was sad to see him get shot so quickly after his long awaited return. Guess he's too busy doing Fringe to appear on too many episodes of Lost. Thanks for all the great posts.
Geoffrey - Thanks :) Well there are deconstruction posts here for analysis... but yeah next week I'm on the review and hope it will be well received...
Chris - the article crashed. People are trying to fix it, but right now editing just makes everything on the page break
Just want to add that I too did not like this recap, I can read a recap right on ABC.com or here on Lostpedia or even WIKIPEDIA!
And getting details incorrect in a review or recap is inexcusable. I'd rather not see this person write here again until they have better skills and better understand the nature ofa review vs recap, and pay better attention to the details of the show.
Yeah that's right, who called John being alive on the island? Bam!
I guess ultimately I agree with the other comments here that it was the mention of Eloise Hawking's name that made Ben kill Locke...another reason that popped up in my mind though for a minute was that maybe the "rule" for the game was indeed that Locke had to die (and Ben knew that), but also not through suicide. Meh, who knows.
Great site, keep it up !
I thought the possibility of Ben killing Locke was to prevent a suicide. But he does say after he cleans up his mess. That he will miss him. Implying he would not see Locke alive ever again. But does this make Widmore the good guy. Richard did help locke get his father murdered against Ben's orders. I believe there is a richard/widmore alliance that still is present even in 2008. But with Widmore acting like a dick to Desmond, his reputation definitely needs more light shed.
Um... do we KNOW that "Abaddon is shot dead by Ben"?
I don't remember seeing who shot Abaddon.
Yes, Nickb123, we need to quit it with the guest reviewers.
Like Harry Knowles' guest appearance with Roger Ebert, these guest writers contribute nothing of substance.
Plain_Gillian:
Yes, Ben admitted he shot Abaddon when asked by John.
"with Widmore acting like a dick to Desmond, his reputation definitely needs more light shed"
No doubt. The characters of Widmore and Ben were made both clearer and at the same time more enigmatic in this episode. It is clearer to me that they are both manipulators. It is clearer to me that Ben is dangerously unstable and capable of almost anything. Widmore's character has been expanded to make him more sympathetic; IF you can believe anything he says, that is. He certainly seems to help Theresa with no legal reason forcing him because experiments he funded caused her problem. Clearly, he was responsible for getting Locke onto 815. But why are both of these men saying the same thing about wanting all of the 6 to return and claiming Locke is so all important?
Here is another more controversial idea that I don't is a fact, but just an interesting thought: Widmore, as manipulator, who seems perhaps to have been working with Eloise, was "a dick" to Desmond. But what if this was not necessarily pure disrespect and contempt, but rather manipulation to get him to the Island? Maybe his disrespect was a tool he used to weaken Desmond's resolve to marry Penny, and together with the manipulation by Eloise, cause him to do something that would get him where they feel he needed to be?
Oops! Thanks Geoffrey
"But he does say after he cleans up his mess. That he will miss him. Implying he would not see Locke alive ever again."
Maybe he did think Locke would stay dead, and maybe the Island changed the rules.
Did jack, kate, and Hurly just flash into the 70's and the rest crashed on the island in modern times? i'm a little confused.
imLost:
I at first thought that they went back to the 70's at about the time where we saw Faraday working with Dharma in the first episode (?). However, I remembered later that we saw Caesar searching through papers and other things at a Dharma site, so maybe this time is after Dharma was destroyed. Otherwise, why would they have no one manning that site?
So do you guys just review each others reviews, or do you actually have thoughts about the show? I thought the acting in this episode was amazing, some of the best I have seen on television in a long time. I was tearing up during the Locke suicide/ Ben saves him scene. Just intense.
Chris L: Lol! Well played, sir. Well played.
Im pretty much pro-Locke no disrepsect to jack. The show started perfectly with him in cloak on the beach. I had to listen to IIana again after I read locke was found standing on water thatss crazy.. I hope they show more of this next ep. And I definitely didnt see the nature of his death coming. Good writing overall. I think every character seems to have a purpose. I keep seeing the total of episodes getting from 12-17 on some sites. Great news
I came to realize something this morning. Jack did not have his father's casket to bury, they had a memorial service after the O6 returned.
After seeing John Locke's return to life on the island after dying in the "real world" I think it's quite possible Christian probably did the same.
Remember when Jack so vividly saw his father at the coast?
Why would Locke see Christian as Jacob when he's never met Christian in his entire life?
That just ties Jack deeper into the island as a leader (think Luke Skywalker and the writers' obsession with Star Wars :))... and maybe has something to do with the way Jack was interested in the old military picture in te Lamppost.
Ben killed Locke (I believe) because he had just admitted to Ben that he couldn't get the job done. He was going to keep his promise to Jin to keep Sun from coming back. Since Ben knows that Sun has to go back, it was crucial for him to make sure that that would happen. So he killed Locke, not out of malice, but like Locke with a knowledge of what had to be done. In killing Locke, he also spared him the indignity of suicide, which normally wouldn't make much difference, but since Locke would be coming back to life...
Seth: I thought of this recently too. At first I assumed that the primary reason was Locke's mention of Eloise Hawking--due to the timing, primarily. That still could be true, but I also agree with you that Ben is convinced that ALL of them have to return, and so, since Locke will not be the one to convince Sun, Ben needs to get rid of Locke because Sun must believe Jin is still alive in order to be convinced to return. It was important that there not be the contradictory story that John would surely tell her. Ben also might know she is determined to kill him which would be another reason to be able to pull that rabbit (ring) out of the hat.
Seth, I like your comment: "In killing Locke, he also spared him the indignity of suicide". We might take into consideration, with all the religious symbolism that suicide is considered a sin and in some cases a direct ticket to Hell. Perhaps Ben knew that if John kills himself it would be impossible for John to resurrect/reanimate (haha). Ben did seem quite sincere in his final (post death) comments to John, but with Ben it is always hard to tell how genuine he actually is. Cheers all!
"Why is there a dead Pakistani on my couch!?"
Don't you think Ben stopped John from committing suicide because if you were on the Island, you can't kill yourself. (Michael tried twice, but couldn't)
Ben knows that John has to die also and has to return to the Island, dead, in a casket. I don't believe as soon as Locke mentions Eloise, this triggers the murder. That's just me.
The previous Anonymous comment is completely identical to my thoughts. It was already established that John had to die. It was also established that the O6 had to replicate as closely as possible the first trip to the Island, which includes a dead guy in a coffin.
I also got the impression that the information about John having Jin's ring was news to Ben, not his mention of Eloise. Ben had already met with her. (Ok with all the time differences it can be difficult to nail down exactly when certain things occur in relation to others but this is my understanding.)
So I am also of the opinion that it wasn't mentioning Eloise that triggered Ben's murder of John.
I also agree with the previous comment that John may not have been able to kill himself, just as Michael could not when he tried.
Perhaps some day we will have the answer.
Until then, goodbye and namaste.
Hi all,
I wanted to run this past a few lost fans as I'm a bit confused by this episode.
Remember at the end of season 4 when Jack tells Ben it has been about a month since he has seen Locke? In the episode that titles this discussion it kinda makes out that John kills himself straight away after seeing Jack. Either there are about 4 weeks missing since Locke sees Jack and his suicide attempt or the writers stuffed up.
If Locke had killed himself and his body not found for about a month, I doubt he would be cleaned up and put in a coffin in public areas.
Jacks beard is not very grown either when Locke arrives in his hospital. Also Jack tells Kate at the beginning of season 4 that he has been flying with Oceanic every Friday before he sees the article about "Jeremy Bentham".
So my question is, did Locke kill himself almost immediately after seeing Jack and his body simply not discovered for almost a month or are 3 or so weeks unaccounted for in LOST that we will discover? Or (and I'm hoping I'm wrong) the writers simply stuffed up a bit and did a quick and nasty tie up of all the lose ends. If so, at the expense of satisfying me with a credible timeline.
Any thoughts, ideas, comments would be greatly appreciated.
Post a Comment