Jack, Kate, and Charlie, having at least somewhat recovered from the terrifying incident at the cockpit, trek home through the jungle. Kate asks Charlie what he was doing in the bathroom, and he makes up a quick lie, telling her that he was getting sick. Of course, we all know that instead he was getting his heroin which he left in the bathroom. Charlie mentions he's a coward, an opinion Kate is quick to refute. Cowardice is a theme that will run through Lost with Charlie, and later, Desmond.


Meanwhile, Michael approaches Sun and Jin looking for Walt. Of course, this won't be the last time he loses Walt, and each search attempt that he'll make will just get more and more annoying. Sun pretends not to speak English, even though she really knows how from her lessons with Jae Lee (which turned into quite a bit more than just lessons). Michael goes off again, looking for Walt, who's looking for Vincent. He finds Kate's handcuffs on the ground near some fuselage. Michael sees the handcuffs, and gets a little worried.

Sayid volunteers to help with the transciever, the first glimpse we get of Sayid's technical prowess, which will eventually be most useful when taking the core out of Jughead in "The Incident." Sawyer also calls Hurley "lardo." He'll later become good friends with Hurley, but for now he's sticking to weight-related nicknames. Hurley instead buddies up with Sayid, and they trade names. Sayid later reveals that he was in the Republican Guard, shocking Hurley.

Jack, meanwhile, works on the marshal, who will be dead very soon. Jack's relying on chance, but he is going to try to fix the marshal. Kate tells Jack that she's going on a hike, despite Jack's warning about the marshal.
Jin's abusiveness to Sun is shown when he slaps her hand after a reach to get food, and you can see her loathing of him in her eyes. Instead, he gives that food to the other survivors, and she defiantly opens the top buttons of her shirt. Hurley laughingly turns down Jin, angering him slightly. Walt, meanwhile, read's Hurley's comic book in Spanish. The comic will later be proxied with Brian K. Vaughn's Y: The Last Man (or El Ultimo Hombre) when Hurley boards Flight 316.
While Charlie uses some powerful drugs, Jack enlists Hurley to once again use his inventory skills to find antibiotic drugs for the marshal. After Shannon decides that she's going on the hike with Kate and Sayid to prove her worthiness to Boone, there's a humorous scene when a stoned Charlie shows up.
SHANNON: You're going, aren't you?
CHARLIE: Yeah, are you?
SHANNON: Yup.
CHARLIE: Yeah, I'm definitely going.
Jack, meanwhile, talks to Michael, and discovers that Michael doesn't know much about Walt, and reveals that Vincent is actually still alive, elating Michael at the chance to be a hero in his son's eyes. If Jack hadn't offered him this as a chance to be noble, who knows what Michael would have done. He might have gone so far as to put himself as a deckhand on a freighter just to blow it up, or something drastic like that.

Claire writes in her diary (the same diary that Charlie will read after she's kidnapped), when Jin offers her some fish. She takes a bite, and though she doesn't necessarily like it, she feels Aaron kick, something she is elated about, and makes an uncomfortable Jin touch her belly.

Jack needs Hurley's help to hold down the marshal while he operates, but Hurley has Mr. Friendly synbrome and can't stand the sight of blood. Hurley faints. Meanwhile, after confirming that the bear was a polar bear, the survivors confront Sawyer about where he got the gun. He says he got it from a U.S. marshal, and they accuse him of being the prisoner, though in reality it was actually Kate. Kate takes the gun and pretends to not know how to use it (a con she used once before in "Whatever the Case May Be".) There's a little heat between Sawyer and Kate, but nothing too much -- Kate obviously dislikes Sawyer.

The marshal meanwhile wakes up in the middle of surgery, asking Jack where Kate is. She's with the group with Sayid, when he discovers that the transciever has a bar. They pick up a transmission, which Sayid speculates could be from a satphone. Sorry Sayid, but you won't be seeing one of those until Naomi crashes on the Island. They hear a French transmission (from Rousseau), which Shannon translates to say "Please help me. Please, come get me. I'm alone now. On the island alone. Please, someone come. The others, they're dead. It killed them. It killed them all." Rousseau is of course referring to the sickness, which happened to her team after Montand was dragged beneath the Temple walls by the monster, and her team followed. What was the sickness? Was it a possession, like what Jacob's enemy did to Locke? We know that Robert, Lacombe, and Brennan weren't the same after they went into the hole...were the possessed by the monster? Either way, Danielle was right. It killed them all. Or rather, she killed them all.

You can discuss "Pilot, Part 2" in this forum thread. You can find others' reviews of this episode at the Lostpedia hub. Look for my review of "Tabula Rasa" Thursday.
Rewatching this, I had a thought about Aaron not kicking in the womb until the moment Claire ate what Jin gave her (I always assumed it was some weird unappetizing echinoderm or mollusk or something). What if Aaron died in the crash, and was reanimated by Jacob? Kind of awful, I know.
ReplyDeleteAlso, the polar bears got the fish biscuits faster than Sawyer because they're BIGGER than Sawyer -- remember how he had to put a rock here, throw something there, just to reach all the moving parts?
Another great write up Sam.
ReplyDeleteYou wrote: "Of course, this won't be the last time [Michael] loses Walt, and each search attempt that he'll make will just get more and more annoying."
Absolutely my sentiments exactly.
Just noticed this time through...Charlie doesn't seem to make it back to the midsection of the plane before the plane is torn apart. He buckles into a seat in what seems to be the front section of the plane after coming out of the bathroom. Any comments on this?
ReplyDeletePerhapsin episode one, when flight 815 crashed on the island, they are in the past or in the future? Maybe its not 2004 at all.....
ReplyDeleteThey're in the present - remember, we see Ben go to the flame to see the tv footage for missing 815.
ReplyDeleteHow did Dharma train the bears to push the wheel??
Dharma didn't know about the wheel, well... they didn't know it was a wheel and we don't know that they touched it/ trained things to touch it...
ReplyDeleteI think the skeleton was there because they tried to send the bear through time via the chamber, like they did with the rabbits.
My theory has been, and still is, one where Jacob and his counterpart (Flocke i spose), always have 2 different sides of which are fighting. You had Americans/Others, Others/Dharma, 815/Others, 316/Others. They are continuously fighting for control, neither really gaining ground, until the end of the 5th season^^.
ReplyDeleteI've never made that connection between the bear, the wheel, and the drop point until now, thanks. But perhaps the bear was put into the chanmber, as mentioned. Does anyone remember if the collar was made of metal?
ReplyDeleteIt's always bothered me how when they shoot the polar bear they're more concerned about Sawyer than the fact there is a FREAKIN POLAR BEAR in a South Pacific tropical island.
ReplyDeleteCharlie's checkered shoes, and checkered past.
ReplyDeleteHurley passing out on the Marshall. Too funny!
Boone walks up to Shannon sunbathing. He asks if she want to help sort out clothing. Shannon replies "Your wasting your time. They're coming."
Thought that was interesting given the end of S5.
The introduction of Danielle (plea for help, and "it killed them all" Smokey reference) and Dharma polar bear from Hydra Island (that had to be a very old bear).
Kate "remembering" the breakup of the tailsection and the reveal that she is the prisoner. Sawyer recognizing a fellow con. Sadly, this version of Kate is replaced with drama queen/love quadrangle in S2,3,4,5. Will we get her back in S6?
Excellent editing and cinematography, score, etc. Loved it.
Sawyer accuses Sayid of being the fugitive claiming that he noticed Sayid's hands under a blanket sitting in business class. Funny because Ilana has Sayid handcuffed on flight 316!
ReplyDeleteI am a big fan of Sun and Jin and being Korean myself found that as a way to convince my mom and brother to watch and also get hooked on Lost. I love it when Sun unbottons her top after Jin slaps her hand. Here we see the very first glimpse of what her character is capable of. She can be a vengeful b**** as seen in season five.
I found Lottery Ticket's observation about Charlie's shoes interesting. Shoes seem to play an interesting role in Lost. Remember the red converse? Christian's shoes, dead Locke's
shoes, Kate taking shoes off the dead body? Just a thought.
Finding out Rousseau's looped message was playing for 16 years is what really hooked me to the show. I'm with Charlie, really, where are they?!?
BTW the polar bear found in the desert on 'Confirmed Dead' appeared to have a leather collar, it was not metal.
After rewatching the backgammon scene I agree that this is one of the most important scenes of the series.
ReplyDeleteNotice that Locke refernces that the game is "two sides, light vs dark" and that it was played in ancient times and is older than Jesus Christ. The significance of this can be drawn from S5 finale when we first see Jacob and Enemy in ancient times and light and dark clothing and they conflict over whether or not people should be coming to the Island. Enemy states that he wants to kill Jacob but knows he can't until he finds a loophole.
Enter Locke, who magically can walk the day of the crash. I have a belief that the Enemy has already conquered Locke. Notice that when he asks Walt if he wants to know a secret that we later find out that all he told Walt was that a "miracle" happened to him. He never told Walt he could not walk before. Locke seems a little to happy to be there even if he can walk, and the fact that he is playing an ancient game in which light plays dark is significant. Someone else had a theory that the Island was playing a game with the people on it, why not Jacob and his nemesis.
Also, the Enemy states to Jacob that he has no idea what he had to go through to get there at the end of S5. I believe he is referencing all of Locke's trials and tribualtions on and off the Island after the crash. I believe the Island was testing him(the Enemy), just like it did Ben. I also belive that the Island wanted Jacob dead for inviting people to come to the Island. That is why the smoke monster (which happens to be dark) manifests itself to Ben as his dead daughter and tells him to do whatever Locke says, which we now know was the Enemy.
How cool would it be if the writers were already foreshadowing this endgame in the second episode of the entire series. Thoughts?
I've read a few comments here that I feel need commenting on.
ReplyDeleteFirst, Jason wrote that the polar bears got the fish biscuits faster than Sawyer because they're bigger. I don't think that's what Tom meant when he made that comment to Sawyer. Their size had nothing to do with it (though it didn't hurt). I'm guessing it took three polar bears to get the biscuits, one to work each step (though we've only seen two polars bears, so maybe one of them was quite dexterous). So, what Tom was saying is that it took two or three polar bears less time to work together to figure out the fish biscuit mousetrap than it did one man.
Which leads me to the next comment from Anonymous: "Dharma didn't know about the wheel, well... they didn't know it was a wheel and we don't know that they touched it/ trained things to touch it..."
Let's not forget that this season we only saw snippets of the Dharma Initiative from 1974 and '77 and learned a bit more about the years in between through inference. The Purge didn't take place until 1992 (or thereabouts). There's still much we don't know about the DI in the years after 1977 and considering that they built a whole station above the wheel and that the polar bear found in Tunisia had the Hydra collar on it, it is certainly plausible that they did know about the wheel.
As for loophole815's thoughts on Locke, I cannot accept that Locke was actually dead the moment he arrived on the island the first time. First of all, I believe that the loophole has to do with "Enemy" physically inhabiting the on-island deceased. It always struck me as odd that so many characters were buried (some even alive - thankfully) on the Island. Yet, those that weren't we've seen again: Christian, Yemi, Locke. If Ben did in fact bury Alex, that would be the exception. Yemi is an interesting case though. His line "You speak to me as though I am your brother" has stuck in my head since finding out the real Locke is dead.
Plus, consider Locke's change in character after the crash of flight 316. Once willing to follow the island virtually without guidance, he comes back and needs to see Jacob. While we now know his true motivation wasn't confirmation but assassination, at the time after 316, it felt like a much different Locke.
I think both viewpoints about Locke are correct:
ReplyDeleteJacob 'gave him life' after the window fall. But,
anti-Jacob, had ALREADY, by that time, semi-possessed Locke (which is what he referred to when saying how complex his plotting had been)...
So, perhaps the 'loophole' is that TWO people (a failsafe one?) whom Jacob has 'given life to' are required to kill him. He gave life to baby-Ben as well; and then, Locke pushed him into the fire.
I would challenge the whole "light vs. dark" as an old misleading concept. Dark is simply the absence of light. The alleged "conflict" is the stuff of human misunderstanding, as in "good guys and bad guys" or "us and those other guys".
ReplyDeleteIn fact, part of the charm of this story is its sly look at the human tendency to demonize those who are not like us. The characters actually call the alleged bad guys "the Others". Human history is one long repetition of creating conflicts over trumped up differences. No wonder the man in black is disgusted with it all.
Lapidus says that self-proclaimed good guys can't be trusted, but really the whole set up cannot be trusted. Instead of the conflict of light and dark, it becomes more interesting to begin to learn to...wait for it... "Live Together" To me, that feels like the real message of this whole big beautiful story. (So few of these characters are able to get it right, so let us take a moment to honor Rose, Bernard, and Vincent, all of whom seem to have found themselves.) The rest of us, except for possibly Sawyer and Juliet, remain hopelessly Lost.
To Neil, he needed to see Jacob before, season 3, Man Behind the Curtain (watched it last night, nice timing eh?)
ReplyDeleteI wish someone would put the nail in the coffin with Locke; he clearly was NOT Jacob's Nemesis when first on the island. This is just ridiculous to assume; we worked out that Locke wasnt Locke by the fact that he was acting wierd after 316. Thus he isn't the same person as after 815. How can he have taken over Locke's body when he didn't die (he hasn't taken a living persons body so how can we assume that he can). Nobody has been hiding another box with John's body in it since the first season, and after seeing Ilana's box will bring theirs out for a bit of "it was my idea first". Ridiculous theory.
In reference to the Locke conundrum. I feel as though the enemy did not inhabit Locke's body until after the crash of 316. It seems to me that if Jacob's enemy were inhabiting Locke's body he would have had no problem killing Locke's father when Ben presented him with the knife. Instead Locke could not do it and his passage as leader of the others was halted.
ReplyDeleteI also agree with what some of the others have written. His actions are different. Anyway the body of John Locke was in the silver container. The enemy may just be assuming his form.
After reading several posts I agree with Neil's assessment of the Locke situation best. I haven't rewatched all the seasons yet and forgot some of the stuff Locke did or did not do(i.e. not killing his Dad) so the post 316 flight theory makes way more sense than my original post. I just found it interesting that way back then Locke referred to backgammon and it clearly looks as though the writers knew back then what the endgame was going to be.
ReplyDeletePerhaps this was obvious and everybody knows about it already. But when Sawyer said to Kate "I know your type" do you think that he knew that Kate was a no good con artist at that moment?
ReplyDelete