Sunday, May 31, 2009

The Lost Rewatch: 1x01 "Pilot, Part 1"

This is my first blog post of the Lost Rewatch, and I can't say that I'm not excited. Even though this blog will only be covering the first of 103 hours, I'm ready to start watching my favorite TV show from the beginning. We're going back to where it all began -- before the Others, before the flash forwards, before the time travel, before the Jughead. We're going back to "Pilot, Part 1."

As with every great series, Lost starts with an iconic shot that will come to define the series. After the episode starts off with that blurred Lost title, we get that shot: Jack's eye snapping open, dilating quickly. (Here's a fun fact: that pupil was actually the product of CGI.) This shot, in a way, remains relevant for the entire series. Not only does the eye, through its rapid dilation, convey the confusion and fear that will underline much of the mystery of the series, but it also shows that the show is more about the characters. Someone more eloquent than me once said that the "eye is the window to the soul," and surely this shot represents that we will be examining the very soul of these characters from week to week. Perhaps close-up shots of eyes have opened eighteen episodes and been seen in eighteen more. We'll see this particular shot of Jack's eye again in "316," in which Jack returns to the Island. In fact, this scene will almost be perfectly repeated, with Jack awakening in the middle of the jungle and running toward the sound of someone screaming. Does this have significance? If Jack landed in a similar place after being teleported out of Flight 316, does this mean that he was possibly teleported out of Flight 815?

As Jack is still gathering his bearings, he is visited by Vincent, who walks up to him slowly before running off into the jungle. If you watched the Missing Pieces mobisodes, you'll know that Vincent was told to go wake up Jack by who appears to be Christian Shephard (but I think is Jacob's nemesis). Jack then looks at the pocket vodka that Cindy gave to him while he was on the plane, and then begins to run haphazardly through the bamboo, eventually coming out on the beach, and noticing the large amount of flaming fuselage sitting further down the beach. But before he does that, he passes a white tennis shoe hanging from a tree. The shoe seems to match the ones that Jack gave Christian to be buried in, which he talked about with Kate in "316." Does this have any significance? Probably not. It's probably just some mildly symbolic item to hint that there's been a plane crash before we actually see the fuselage seconds later.

And as Jack surfaces onto the beach, we hear screaming, probably from Shannon. Jack dodges a turbine and runs through the wreckage of a familiar red, white, and blue plane: Oceanic Flight 815 is sitting on the beach. As Jack passes the open cabin, you can see a person hanging upside down and flailing in their seat. This person's hand will later hang into the frame as Jack looks into the cabin after the chaos subsides.

Jack looks over to a turbine, and we see the second person that will become a main character: Charlie, standing next to the turbine, in shock. Jin screams for Sun, Michael screams for Walt, Shannon screams for Boone, and a man screams for someone off-screen to stay away from the gas. This wouldn't be notable, save for the fact that this actor will appear once again as the mortician in "White Rabbit," the episode that will kick off next week.

A man trapped under a piece of metal screams for help (this man is played by Dale Radomski, a stuntman who appeared as an Other in season two and has conducted an interview with Lostpedia), and Jack rushes to his aid. Jack can't do it on his own, so he calls Locke and another man over to help him out. This is probably both the first and last time that Jack and Locke will work together for the same means. It was nice while it lasted.

And then there's Claire, eight months pregnant with her bundle of joy Aaron, screaming for help. Jack can hardly finish tying off the wounded man's tourniquet before he's rushing to help Claire, who, even though he doesn't know it, is his long-lost half sister, and the indirect season that he was even on the plane. It's a sad irony that won't be revealed until the season three episode "Par Avion," but it only adds that much to retrospective viewing.

Boone tries to perform CPR on an unconscious Rose, who, ironically, will outsurvive him for at least three years. Locke tries to warn Bad Twin author Gary Troup to get out of the turbine's way, but Troup is probably too busy worrying about his girlfriend, flight attendant Cindy Chandler (who survived with the tail section) to get out of the way, and instead stops and asks Locke to repeat himself, a mistake that costs him his life as he is sucked into the turbine, which promptly explodes. Of course, as that turbine blows, there's that flash of black swooping across the screen that many believed to be the smoke monster before it was confirmed to be just bad CGI.

Jack calls to Hurley, who is standing nearby, to stay with Claire. Hurley responds less than favorably, but I think we all know that the "you gotta be kidding me" line was referencing his bad "luck," not Jack's request for help. He asks for Jack's name, to which Jack replies Jack. After pointing out Boone's incompetence as a lifeguard and sending him on a pointless mission to collect pens (which we will see another angle of in "Expose"), Jack saves Rose's life. As soon as he tells her to take deep breaths, the wing sways and threatens to crush Hurley and Claire, who are saved just in the nick of time by Jack. Sure, he's being noble, but that need to fix things is very, very evident.

After that explosion, the debris of which nearly crushes Charlie, the hubbub seems to subside, and Jack wanders through the wreckage, shellshocked. He then looks into the cabin and sees the hand dangling over his head. It's a sobering moment for anyone just beginning Lost: the show is not afraid of death. Boone returns with a handful of pens, showing them to Jack. This is foreshadowing at its greatest; if Boone is dumb enough to think that the pens still matter, he obviously won't make it very long on the Island. And he won't.

Jack picks out the sewing kit, and runs away into the jungle to sew himself up. Kate appears (rubbing her wrists where the handcuffs were), and he tells her to sew him up. In a later continuation of this scene, Jack will tell her the "count to five" story, which we recently experienced firsthand in "The Incident, Parts 1 & 2." As you remember, right after that story went down, Jack met Jacob for the first (and maybe only) time. Jacob, one of the biggest mysteries of seasons three through five, has been right on the edge of one of Jack's biggest memories. The sewing scene also serves as the beginning of the Jack and Kate relationship that has been so hotly debated amongst fans. It's the beginning of a complicated and often fickle relationship. But this is one of the few episodes where Sawyer is not an obstacle in the relationship between Jack and Kate.

But he's introduced in the very next scene, lighting a cigarette next to the fuselage, and walking around angstily. In a deleted scene that originally took place within this one, Charlie came up and asked Sawyer for a cigarette. Sawyer gives Charlie the cigarette he is smoking, and lights another. Sawyer actually looks sad for a moment before continuing down the beach. Claire's standing near the surf, letting the waves lap over her feet. Kate would later call this practice "sinking," in the episode "Raised By Another," because the waves would carry the sand away. This shot of Claire would be reused in the mobisode, "Jack, Meet Ethan. Ethan? Jack." Meanwhile, Hurley sorts the food, a role he will once again have when the Swan station is discovered to have a large pantry. And there's the ever-mysterious Locke, staring out at the waves. Just this one shot let's us know that there's something...special...about him.

At twelve minutes in, we meet Sayid for the first time, building a fire with Charlie's help. And meanwhile, Rose holds Bernard's wedding ring, kissing it. She knows, somehow, that Bernard is alive, even though he's on the other side of the Island. I'm not suggesting anything supernatural, but Rose's faith is very solid. I think she'd be on Eko's side in the science vs. faith debate.

That night, Charlie writes "FATE" on his finger bandages, a somewhat iconinc moment for the character, and one that was immortalized with the Charlie action figure which is currently sitting next to me on my desk. Sayid begins to express discomfort about the rescuers' lateness. Shannon and Boone bicker, setting up the light rivalry between them, which will soon end, as they will be the first two main characters to die. Shannon references the plane's black box, something that Captain Gault later claims to have with him on the Kahana, though the box in his possession was a fake created by Charles Widmore, who we unfortunately will not meet for quite a while.

Walt's coldness toward Michael is shown as they lie in front of a campfire. Of course, at this point they hardly know each other. This relationship will come full circle, as Walt will eventually come to accept Michael before shunning him once again after learning of Michael's murders of Ana Lucia and Libby. It doesn't look like there will be another chance for them, because Michael was killed onboard the Kahana. Meanwhile, Jin establishes guidelines for Sun in a hard, domineering way. He's been changed by working for her father, but the relationship between Sun and Jin will drastically change over the course of the show. Sun shouldn't be pitied, she's actually more manipulative than he is. He may not be the best husband, but he never cheated on her.

Jack and Kate watch over the marshal Edward Mars, who was actually transporting Kate to Los Angeles to stand trial for the murder of her father, Wayne Janssen. Kate and the marshal have quite a history together, but it'll end soon when he dies from the shrapnel (well, fromSawyer's bullet and Jack's euthanization, at least). Later, Jack and Kate discuss their experiences of the crash. Jack blacked out, but Kate remembers vividly what happened, telling Jack that the cockpit and the tail both broke off, something we'll see from a better angle when Juliet's book club is interrupted in "A Tale of Two Cities." Jack says he wants to find a cockpit for the transceiver, a mission that they will go on the next day. Jack mentions having taken flying lessons, but it "wasn't for him." Kate volunteers to tag along, something she would do regardless of whether or not they actually want her to -- a personal flaw that will get the best of her in season two's "The Hunting Party." She says that she saw smoke. While that may have been from the cockpit, we also know that the monster frequented that area for a while.

And then enters the monster, the mysteriously Egyptian-related cloud of smoke that tonight terrorizes the survivors by uprooting trees in the jungle. That's not usually the monster's main objective -- usually it's more concerned with judging and killing people. It's obviously not a feral beast, but more of a calculating, judgmental beast whom I personally think is Jacob's nemesis. So is he just asserting his authority, or is Smoky doing something else entirely? Locke looks around at the jungle, hearing for the first time its mysterious qualities (aside from the healing of his paraplegia). Walt asks if the thing shaking the trees is his dog, Vincent, one of the dumbest lines of the entire series. Or is it? Vincent's always been enigmatic, but is this some hint that he's related to the monster? Walt's generally been shown to be somewhat smart and "special," and that question would be out of character for him if there's not something else behind that line. Charlie, deadpan as always, sarcastically comments "terrific."

And then we get our first flashback, the very first one in a very long line. It doesn't go back very far, though; just to earlier that day. Jack's on the plane, looking out the window at the wing that would later threaten to fall on Hurley and Claire. Flight attendant Cindy Chandler asks him how is drink is, to which he replies that it's not a very strong drink. She's charismatic and sweet, and hands him two small bottles of vodka, which he will later use to disinfect the gash on his back. She walks away, and Jack will not see her again until the season three episode "Stranger in a Strange Land," because she was kidnapped by the Others during her time with the tail section.

Jack dumps the first bottle of vodka into his drink and takes a rather large sip, perhaps foreshadowing to his alcoholic tendencies once rescued from the Island. He stands up to go the bathroom, but is passed by Charlie, who we find out in the next episode was running from the flight attendants in order to get a fix in the bathroom. Jack looks over, and he's sitting next to Rose, whose husband Bernard has gone to the bathroom in the tail section of the plane. Rose won't see Bernard again until the episode "Collision," when Bernard arrives back at the beach camp. The plane shakes, and for a brief moment, Locke is seen sitting behind Rose. Jack tries to reassure her, but the turbulence just gets worse. Jack promises to keep Rose company until Bernard gets back from the bathroom. Just as Jack tells her not to worry, the plane shakes, and some fool who forgot to fasten his seatbelt is flung into the ceiling. Masks drop, and the plane continues to fall until Jack presumably blacks out, ending the flashback.

Back on the Island, the survivors discuss what exactly the monster was. Rose said it sounded familiar to her, even though she grew up in the Bronx. This is a reference to the fact that part of the audio used to create the monster is rendered from the reciept dispenser of a taxicab, though this subtle in-joke is often taken by fans to mean more than it actually does. Hurley also says "technically, you know, we don't even know if we're on an Island." This is also an in-joke about the fact that if Lost hadn't been picked up, the producers jokingly stated that they'd have the show end with the survivors being in Florida.

Kate and Jack prepare to leave for the cockpit, but first Kate needs to get better shoes, which she morosely accomplishes by removing them from a corpse. Down the beach, Locke is eating an orange, and gives her the infamous orange-peel grin, which Kate does not appreciate. However, audiences did, because it has been lauded as one of the funniest moments of the series. Another funny moment comes a few seconds later, as Hurley misspells "bodies" (b-o-d-y-s) in an attempt to protect Walt's innocence, but Walt corrects his spelling. Jack then alerts them that he's going to look for the cockpit. Charlie, remembering that he left his drugs in the cockpit bathroom, decides to tag along.

On the way to the cockpit, they trek across the Mesa, a location that has been used multiple times: it was the location of the 1954 Others camp and it was where Ben killed his father during the Purge. Kate, finding Charlie familiar, discovers that he's a member of the band DriveShaft. She finds this coincidence interesting; Jack doesn't have time for such small talk. Kate says that DriveShaft was good, but Charlie insists that the band still is. He'll later accept that the band is no more in "Greatest Hits," when he says that they "had their moment in the sun." And as they walk on, Vincent watches from afar. Is he possessed by either Jacob or Jacob's enemy to look after the other survivors? After all, they both seemed pretty interested in the affairs of humans. It couldn't be hard to possess a dog, right?

It starts to rain. Charlie comments that this is "day turning into night" type weather (notice the black and white similarities there). Locke sits out on the beach in the rain, enjoying himself. He's always had an affinity for the rain, as later seen in "Confirmed Dead," when he was able to predict a coming rain.

And then the monster returns, knocking down the trees. Why is it doing that? But Rose knows there's trouble brewing, because Jack, Kate, and Charlie are still in the jungle. The cockpit is soon found, though, and they quickly get inside. It's on an incline, so they struggle to climb up. Jack opens the door to the cockpit, and out flies the co-pilot's body, who obviously died rather quickly. Isn't that familiar? The copilot dies first, while the pilot is left alive? Flight 316, anyone?

They look around for the transciever, but instead find out that the pilot, Seth Norris, is alive. He discovers that he's been out cold for sixteen hours (the numbers were popping up back before we even knew they existed). The pilot reveals that six hours in, the radio went out. They turned back to land at Fiji, but by the time the plane crashed, they were a thousand miles off course. No one would know where they were. Which, as we would later find out, wouldn't matter anyway, because the Island moves a lot. Seth shows them where the transciever is, and then they realize that Charlie's missing. He's actually in the bathroom, getting his drugs. Kate goes out to find him as Seth realizes that the transciever's not working. Suddenly, Charlie pops out of the bathroom, dodging her question why he was in there.

And then the monster lets out its signature howl. The survivors huddle in the cockpit for safety. After it looks like the monster is gone, Seth stupidly sticks his head out the window of the cockpit and is suddenly dragged out by the monster. Why did the monster do this? Did it judge Seth? This was again, one of the strange, almost senseless actions that the monster took in the first season. All I can say was that at least Frank couldn't make it onto that flight, or he'd be gone.

They flee the cockpit with the transciever after the monster knocks the cockpit down, and the monster pursues them. Charlie falls, and calls for Jack to help him. Jack, of course, having something to fix, turns around and helps. Kate flees into a bamboo patch (similar to the one Walt will hide from the polar bear in during "Special,") and screams for Jack. This moment will be immortalized in the Kate action figure. She counts to five to ease her fear, and appears to be a little calmer. Just as she seems to have gained her composure, Charlie appears, startling her. She fears for Jack's life because he hasn't showed up yet. Kate mutters that they "have to go back" for him, the first (but not the last) time this phrase is uttered on the show. Charlie argues, but she goes anyway, and he follows. While looking for him, Charlie expresses his jealousy that Kate didn't shout his name.

They see Seth's pilot ensignia in the mud, and then they see the reflection of a body in a tree. Jack appears and says it's the pilot, but the pilot's mangled body leads Charlie to ask how something like that happens. The body was originally planned to be Jack's, as a ploy by the producers to shock the audience, but this was eventually abandoned so that the audience was not alienated from the pilot episode on. However, this idea of killing off the supposed leader was revisted with Flight 316, when Caesar, the supposed leader of the survivors, was gunned down by Ben in "Dead is Dead."

As the pilot's mangled body is revealed, the all too familiar cut to black with the word LOST in white is shown, a formula that would continue until the season five finale, when the end title was inverted.

And thus ends the first episode of the Lost Rewatch. Sorry for the long post, but there was so much to cover. The next ones will be at least a little shorter, I promise.

You can discuss "Pilot, Part 1" in this forum thread. You can find others' reviews of this episode at the Lostpedia hub.

And also, don't forget to work on the "Pilot, Part 1" article on Lostpedia and improve it as much as possible!

Look for my review of "Pilot, Part 2" on Wednesday.

46 comments:

  1. Great write-up, I read it all! I havent watched it yet, but im on a different schedule to everyone else :).
    I never realized many of those small things you pointed out. E.g. black-box.

    P.S. JACOB's ENEMY is everywhere!!! I love the fact everyones saying everything is a form of Jacob's Enemy it could of been Jacob as well btw.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I thought this was a fabulous synopsis that integrated the knowledge we have now of characters' fates and other mysteries of the island. I hope you don't feel the need for these to be shorter. I loved how in depth it was, especially since I watched this episode again yesterday, and you brought up a couple things I hadn't noticed.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great job and thank you....see you Wednesday

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nice recap. I'd add that when "Locke sits out on the beach in the rain, enjoying himself", is not so much about having an "affinity for the rain", but more related to the fact that he can suddenly walk again after a long time, and everything about life seems beautiful to him now.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dr. McPhearson here.

    Great write-up. I do have to disagree with you on something though.

    You said that Seth was killed by the Monster, and that if Frank Lapidus had been the pilot of Fligth 815 like he was supposed to be, he would have been a goner too. This is where I disagree.

    I'm wondering: could the Monster have killed Seth BECAUSE he wasn't Frank? Perhaps the Monster wanted Frank on the Island the whole time, and since Seth wasn't even supposed to be there, the Monster course corrected and wiped him out, as though it were Strike One.

    But after 316, Frank's fine. He's obviously still got some work to do on the Island.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Looking back on Locke...his obvious joy of just walking and sitting in the rain mirrors his return on 316. Remember how he said the mango was the best he had ever had.
    We thought at first he was brought back to life didn't we? It was an echo of how good it was to be alive and back on the Island.
    Now we know it was Unlocke then and sometimes I wonder if Locke died in the 815 crash and was used by Unlocke. He would seem so nice like in his flashbacks..so humble and beat down. Then a mean streak would come out even in the first season.
    I know..how did he appear again as Locke. And was Ben Jacob's loophole to kill him again by strangling him?

    ReplyDelete
  7. I bet the sudden awakening of seth norris was actually a possession by the smoke monster. Then he leans far enough out the window so nobody can see it leave the body. Then it smacks the body around.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I'd wager, based on everything we've seen, Smokey/Anti-Jacob can't possess bodies--whether alive or dead. Only impersonate the dead on the Island.

    ReplyDelete
  9. A couple things I noticed...

    Jack was the only one to land in the jungle (on their side anyway). Could he have died and been brought back to life by Jacob. Like Locke, after Locke was thrown from the window.

    After Jack left the cockpit, his group encoutered the monster. Could he have had a face to face with it and not told anyone. It seem like after meeting the monster, the survivors begin to have visions. Does this monster look into people to see what he can use to judge/influence them?

    ReplyDelete
  10. When Jack runs out of the bamboo on to the beach we get an interesting camera pan. From first person (Jack) to third person looking a Jack. I have always thought that was important - sort of like an out-of body-shot.

    The removal of shoes from a dead person (Kate) and the putting of shoes on a dead person (Jack), white shoes (dead Christian), black shoes (dead Locke : note that fLocke has taken Christian's black shoes).

    And while Jack sends Boone to look for pens might be a throw away scene, the fact that Jacob gave Sawyer a pen to write the letter at least tells me that writing instruments be important. Jacob writes with a loom. They also made a point to show us that Hurley leaves jail with a pen, money and candy.

    I tried to find the translation of Charlie's morse code on flight 815 (his taping of the ring) but couldn't find anything. If anyone knows morse code, can you please translate.

    Also, the Monster in 2004 certainly has incorporated the drilling equipment, scaffolding, horn, etc. when Radz. breached the highly charged electromagnetic pocket. We first meet Smokey stomping around in the jungle reeking havoc on trees. Can we assume that he is chasing someone? Could that be Ethan? I was also wondering if Smokey learned to drill holes as a result of 1977 incident (Locke's near capture). If Juliet's soul is also now part of Smokey via the incident, I wonder if we will see that played out in Season 1 and 6.

    Cindy and Gary, news to me. Is that cannon? or part of Lost Experience?

    Also, the cuts or marks on Jack and Locke must be significant. Jack as double lines on both left and right of face and Locke a single line across his right eye.

    Jack has two miracle surgeries, the count-to-five gal (Jacob present) and Sara (Desmond present). I wonder if Jacob had something to do with these events.

    The oft seen rings of Lost: Rose and Sun's wedding rings and Charlie's DS.

    I've re-watched Pilots 1 and 2 any number of times of the last four years and I'd swear they get better with each viewing. Best $6 ever spent!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Gary Troup was confirmed by Darlton to be the guy sucked into the turbine. His relationship with Cindy Chandler was part of the Lost experience; she was mentioned in Bad Twin as well.

    But I don't think canonicity matters much with them, does it?

    ReplyDelete
  12. Will the rewatch be happening after the sixth season too, do you think?

    As obviously those very special last 17 episodes are expected to bring alot more information, backstory, fullness and closure to alot of the themes and plots that Lost brings up (even in these early episodes).

    ReplyDelete
  13. Nicely done! I have one small comment to make. Dont you think its significant that Rose says there is something familiar about Smoky, when the Losties hear it moving in the forest?

    ReplyDelete
  14. In reply to Blackout:
    If that line was said in a more recent series, I think it WOULD be significant.
    The fact is, I doubt that in the Pilot episode the directors/producers (Abrams/Cuse/Lindelof) would of thought this far ahead.
    Im guessing they would of had a story lined up, the big things etc. But Rose saying it on the pilot episode and never mentioning it again is TOO small.

    So basically: If it was going to be a major thing in the next series, I HIGHLY expect they would of said something in one the previous series.

    ReplyDelete
  15. A Smokie thought. When we were all blogging that time travel would account for the mysteries on the Island, the producers shot that idea down. Said nope, not time travel yet we now know that it is time travel.
    Around that same time, the blogging about Smokie was nanobot swarms and of course that was shot down by the producers also.
    If they denied time travel yet it was time travel...I wonder if they denied nanobots yet Smokie is a nanobot swarm.

    ReplyDelete
  16. In reply to LotterTicket:
    I thought count-to-five girl and Sara were one and the same??

    ReplyDelete
  17. Luke (John 1:5):
    Jack says in Pilot, Part 1 that count-to-five girl was only 16. Definitely not Sarah. I would add though that Jack definitely conveys to Kate in the sowing scene that HE was the one who came up with the count-to-five, even though it was his father (according to The Incident, 1 and 2). Many explanations may account for that which could tie into the show, but the realist in me believes it was a creative insertion by the writers during season 5, and not "always intended" from the beginning. More on that generally below.

    General comments so far:
    I'm 30 minutes into Pilot, Part 1 and again I'm always astonished by subtle things that I didn't (or couldn't have) picked up on during previous viewings. Now that we have some inkling of a broader scheme (a la Jacob) it's impossible to view these episodes apart from that.

    All and all the only "new" things I pick up on are subtle i.e. camera angles, underlying music, etc. It makes me wonder how much Giacchino new of the underlying story and what he was conveying. Specific example: most of the scenes with John Locke in these first few episodes are presented with ambiguity. What I mean is that usually the sky is gray, you can't read his expression, or he gives conflicting impressions (think smiling orange) combined with ominous music. Whenever I interpreted this before, I chalked it up to the big reveal in Walkabout when you learn about his healing. But NOW given the integral role as a sort of nexus point for both Jacob's and AJ's (abbreviation for Anti-Jacob) schemes, it makes sense that Locke would be ambiguously presented, etc. Thoughts?

    As usual, these matters are always up for interpretation, and really nothing can be definitively said until the series finale, but it's always interesting to think about just how much the writers had to convey in these opening episodes that related to their whole project and not just the demands of a brand new show trying to hook into a new audience. After 5 years though, I'm willing grant these writers quite a bit in how much mythological exposition they were able to convey in the first season, even if it's all subtle, underlying, ambiguous and ultimately up for interpretation.

    I've also started to create a list in my mind of mysterious comments, etc. that have cropped up during the series that I desperately hope the writers will address but will ultimately forgive them if they don't get to them. Number one on my list: Rose's comment about Smokey on the beach "that sound is so familiar...I'm from the Bronx."

    Final thought (for now): Thank you SO much everyone for this great idea of the Lost Re-Watch. I always re-watch the series (sometimes multiple times) after each season. My TIVO stays completely full of episodes from the previous season until I buy the DVD in the winter, just so I can do this year by year. Already I think Lostpedia will benefit from article editing. I always dream that all our comments will figure into some academic's dissertation years from now when they're pouring over all the documentation created by this Lost phenomenon and its broader cultural/artistic/etc impact. Enjoy the re-watch!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Wonderful synopsis! I'm also of the opinion that Vincent is far more than what he seems. He isn't a mere dog; if he was in the cargo area of the plane, like many pets are kept, it would be very difficult for him to survive the crash.

    Looking forward to the next write-up!

    ReplyDelete
  19. To quote myself in this recap (reading before commenting saves everyone a world of trouble):

    Back on the Island, the survivors discuss what exactly the monster was. Rose said it sounded familiar to her, even though she grew up in the Bronx. This is a reference to the fact that part of the audio used to create the monster is rendered from the reciept dispenser of a taxicab, though this subtle in-joke is often taken by fans to mean more than it actually does.

    ReplyDelete
  20. How much of the first season is canon? I'd be very surprised if the writers had the whole story formed when writing the pilot, or even the first few seasons. (I want them to write a book afterward describing how the story originated and evolved.) I wonder how much that happened in the pilot was to set up later-abandoned plot lines and how much random stuff was ret-conned into importance. For instance, Jack's counting-to-five story was probably intended to have no significance past this episode; now we "know" that the incident was a pivotal interaction with Jack's father and sets up Jack's meeting with Jacob. Also, any reading of Locke's behavior in the pilot as being connected with Esau or Jacob is probably false; I think at this point such a role for Locke had not been thought of. And was the shoe on the tree just a random detail, only later connected with Christian?

    I also wouldn't analyze the monster's behavior too much this early in the series. It's nature and role, I'm sure, changed as the story evolved. When it killed the pilot it was probably being just a wild and dangerous beast, not the judgmental tool and/or manifestation of Jacob and/or Esau.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I wonder if the monster has any connection to the missing statue. I know it looks nothing like it in form, but there are interactions with the monster where it is "stomping" through the jungle. Any thoughts?

    ReplyDelete
  22. The entire series is canon. Certain parts of the series cannot just be overlooked because the producers may not have known what was happening at the time.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I noticed a typo here, fyi... "Claire, who, even though he doesn't know it, is his long-lost half sister, and the indirect season that he was even on the plane."

    I'm assuming that should be 'reason'.

    Otherwise, great write-up.

    To 'Anonymous' a few posts above me, I agree that not everything was planned from the beginning, but many major plot points were, according to the DVD bonus features. There is a short documentary on there describing the genesis of Lost, and they talk about how they came up with a high-level storyline for roughly 5 seasons (if I'm remembering correctly), and also JJ Abrams telling Terry O'Quinn that his role in the first few episodes is minor, but would wind up with a much more significant role (JJ Abrams had worked with Terry O'Quinn on Alias, and recruited him especially for this role).

    Also, I think it was Damon Lindelof who said that the bodies of 'Adam & Eve' would someday prove that they knew where they were going with the series from the beginning.

    Just FYI, you still could be totally right, and plus I haven't seen the DVD bonus features in a while, so I may be remembering things wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Awesome, loved it and i have some interesting theories of Jacob's enemy in pilot part 2

    ReplyDelete
  25. Nice write-up. Your post mentioned "further down the beach" but proper usage, when relating to actual distance, would be "farther".

    Sorry, I just wanted to find something to nitpick about like most everyone else.

    This rewatch is a great idea, I just wish I hadn't started my own re-watch about a month ago. I'm up to S3.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Haha, I just read your blog whilst watching Pilot. Sooo good :D

    ReplyDelete
  27. I tend to believe that it was intentional for the count to 5 story to be different from season 1to season 5. I think the presence of Jacob makes the difference. There could be two different time lines involved. In Jack's version of the story he said he made a choice.

    I wouldn't believe this so much if there wasn't another backstory in the season 5 finale that changed slightly also.

    I think Jack encountered Smokie in the jungle coming back from the cockpit and lied about it like Locke did. Although I'm not sure it was Smokie that Locke seen.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Sayid'sgirl - as the show has repeatedly tried to explain over season 5: What Happened, Happened. There are not different timelines. The "count to five" incident in the OR always happened the way they showed it in The Incident. Jack's failure to mention his father's involvement in the pilot was intentional on his part, though I'm not convinced the writers planned it that way from the beginning. I totally believe Darlton when they say they had a plan from the beginning, but I don't think that necessarily applies to all the small details, just the grander scheme.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Well I had a nice post here explaining my thoughts. But when I copied it, it disappeared and yesterdays post took it's place. Go figure. I'll try to remember what I said.

    nicole
    Ok I may have used the wrong words by saying different timelines. Miles has already said that when Linus turned the wheel time is no longer a straight line for us.
    The 2004 they've experienced is their past as you know. Depending on what happens with the bomb they may experience 2004 differently. If it should come back around for them again. In other words if they were to expeience time from the point in 1977 they are in now through 2004 again. 2004 would be different experiences.

    I agree what happened, happened up to this point. But the bomb may put a twist on things. I hope you understand what I'm trying to say.

    I at first also thought Jack was telling his version of the story to put himself in a good light. Until I realized that Jin and Sun's wedding had some slight variations. And I couldn't believe that they had made 2 continuity errors. Which is why I believe it's intentional.

    This of course is only a theory and I could be completely wrong in my theory. But I still think it was intentional.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Sayid'sgirl - I'm not 100% sure I understand what you mean, so I apologize if I screw it up somehow.
    But I don't think the bomb is going to change anything. "What happened, happened" means that whatever happened with the bomb always happened that way. Nothing they showed about the "incident" gave me any indication that things didn't happen exactly the way we've been told they did. We even saw how Chang lost his arm. And just because the episode ended in a bright light doesn't mean the island exploded, or even that the bomb went off. Lost is great at making you think one thing and then showing you that it was actually something completely different. I'm not jumping into any conclusions about what happened with that bomb until I see next season's premiere. But I feel pretty confident that it didn't change anything.

    I don't know what you mean about the variations in Sun and Jin's wedding. I don't remember the episode where they got married before - I'll look forward to seeing what you mean when I get that far in the re-watch. But as far as the "count-to-five" story - I don't think this is a continuity error. I think it was absolutely intentional. I just don't think it was planned from episode 1. I picture them sitting around the writer's room this season, and someone said "what if we do a flashblack to that count-to-five story, but we show that Jack left out some details? What if we throw Christian in there?" and everyone else said "Oh, that's cool! And that's where we can show Jack meeting Jacob!" and everyone said OK.

    ReplyDelete
  31. niclole
    lol That's ok. I'm rarely understood.

    I agree that what happened, happened up to where the bomb was detonated by Juliet. It's after the bomb explodes that I think all bets are off.That's where what happened, happened stops.
    I'm not sure exactly where Jacob fits in. If he's before or after the bomb explodes.

    Desmond's experience with the electromagnetism when he turned he key was that he traveled through his own past relived it with slight variations and returned to his original time.

    I don't think Jack's story is a continuity error either. I think there was suppose to be 2 stories because there were 2 stories.

    To be fair someone at TLC blog brought up the variations in Jin and Sun's wedding. (Thanks memphish) So when I read this. That's when I decided Jack's version of the story wasn't Jack trying to sound brave but the actual events changed for some reason. And like I said this is all theory and I'm probably wrong. But it seems possible to me.

    I hope this clears my ramblings up a little better.

    By the way. Sun and Jin's wedding (In Translation) is near the end of season 1 so it will be a few weeks before we get to it in the re watch. I'll try to remember to explain the differences then.

    ReplyDelete
  32. I doubt the white tennis shoes in the trees near Jack could be Christian's, because in the mobisode we see that Christian is already wearing the shoes when he tells Vincent to go wake up Jack.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Aboutthe white tennis shoes ... if I remember correctly the coffin with Jack's father was empty, leading us to believe that the apparition of Christian really could be his body somehow come to life. The shoe might signify that the body was thrown out of the coffin somehow, that's why the coffin was empty? And that Christian is in fact Jacob's nemesis, as now seems to be the case?

    ReplyDelete
  34. Charlie wrote "LATE" on his finger bandages in this episode (as evidenced by the bandages being left on the trail when Ethan took Claire and Charlie). "FATE" was written on them later.

    ReplyDelete
  35. I noticed an amusing detail as Jack, Kate and Charlie were off on their trek: Kate wonders if perhaps she and Charlie had met before they crash, and he says (more or less) that it would be very unlikely. What a great example of irony (or even prolepsis) since we will gradually learn of NUMEROUS examples of characters paths crossing prior to Flight 815 (although Kate and Charlie, in fact, do not).

    ReplyDelete
  36. As I am enjoying this post and all it's comments I decide to look down at the clock and of course it was 3:16. I consider LOST to be the greatest piece of entertainment I have ever had the joy of watching. Shortly after this post I will go enjoy the start of my LOST re-watch. Thank you everyone, it's been a pleasure sharing this with you all. Now on to the greatness.....one more time. :)

    ReplyDelete
  37. So very excited about the Lost re-watch. I have the summers off and have my own personal re-watch after each season but am glad to be following a schedule as I am a huge Lost fan and although this is my first contribution to a blog, I have been watching Lost since day one!

    I would like to believe that the white shoe IS significant and in fact the shoe Christian wore. Why else put that image there other than to foreshadow the grim chaos that Jack walks into. When it comes to this show I lean towards the "faith" side. I believe that there has GOT to be a REASON why they are all there.

    Could the reason why Jack left out Christian's presence in his count to five story because he was still so furious at his dad? Remember, they were estranged to say the least. As Kate sews him up, Jack says "I knew I had to deal with it" and sheds a tear. He could be thinking about his father there. Or he could have simply left dad out and told the story the way he did to put Kate at ease from the trauma they've just experienced.

    I think it's so funny to see how characters have stayed consistent throughout the seasons. Kate insisting to come on the trek even when Jack tries to talk her out of it is the first of many such incidents.

    Never really thought much about Vincent but he kind of freaks me out sitting there watching the three trek to the cockpit. If Christian represents the (anti)Jacob as does the other dead people that visit other lostees (Yemi, Hurley's friend from the psych ward) and Vincent is shown being sent from Christian to Jack then maybe, I don't know... maybe Vincent is an evil dog! (silly I know...) I will keep an eye out for him in other episodes.

    ReplyDelete
  38. regarding one of the inconsistencies in the jin/sun wedding, the rings is the most obvious difference. her ring is no longer white gold/platinum as we saw several times throught the seasons (specifically in the episode when she loses her ring). the ring at the wedding jacob went to is gold and looks completely different.

    ReplyDelete
  39. "Walt asks if the thing shaking the trees is his dog, Vincent, one of the dumbest lines of the entire series."

    Sam, I love that you pointed this out. This ranks up there in groan-inducing lines on 'Lost' with Jack asking Ana Lucia how long it will take to build an army (probably the most shamelessly abandoned plot line in the whole series) and that horribly cheeseball question that Sun asks fLocke when he says he wants to take them to see Jacob. These scenes actually make ME feel embarrassed just watching them.

    Also, I loved learning the truth about Jack's "Count to 5" story in "The Incident." It was such an interesting and appropriate revelation that Jack conveniently left his father out of the story. And for those who think that Christian was simply added in to that story for effect in Season 5, I disagree. Christian first arrived (err, appeared) only three episodes later in 'Walkabout.' "White Rabbit" and "All The Best Cowboys Have Daddy Issues" would cement Jack's struggle to distance himself from his father, a conflict/theme that would permeate the series. I believe that Lindelcuse knew what they were doing with his story from the start.

    ReplyDelete
  40. I started rewatching a little early (already up to season 3), and the thing I noticed about the Pilots was that some things didn't quite match up; namely, the monster. In the pilots, it didn't really act like it ever has after, generally going for "coming out of holes and judging people" rather than "riding a bulldozer through the jungle and pulling strangers from planes".

    But the main thing I wanted to mention, was Vincent. While the suggestion that he is something more sounds good, there is an obvious flaw; the mobisode where Christian tells Vincent he has work to do. Christian is generally regarded to be some work of Jacob's Nemesis. Vincent doesn't really seem to have fallen in with this crowd, which would mean, if this theory is subscribed to, that he is with/is an embodiment of Jacob. Hence you can see the flaw of these two co-operating/Jacob taking commands from his nemesis. I think Vincent is what he is; a dog who turns up at convienient times. Jacob may have had as much to do with him as reviving him if he died in the crash as someone above theorised.

    I think, at this infant stage of the series, it's a bit much to look into some things a bit to deeply.

    But I will give credit for avoiding a common phenonomen (sorry can never spell that) of embelishing (another) certain things; taking situations for which there is no evidence or suggestion and theorising thus. Things like Rose being on the island before because of the noise, or other red herrings like that; that mean nothing and should be taken at face value.

    Cheers for a good review

    ReplyDelete
  41. Patrick -
    I do agree with you that Vincent is just a dog. I don't think he's anything more than that. But two things:
    1. I didn't really follow the logic of your argument. What do you mean when you say "Vincent doesn't really seem to have fallen in with this crowd" and how did you make the leap from that to Vincent being an embodiment of Jacob? Can you elaborate?
    2. I hate to be "that girl" - but I have to say it. Damon and Carlton have pretty much said that nothing that happens outside the actual show is canon, so I don't really think we can use the mobisodes as a foundation for any theories. They're just enhancements. (Though I suppose the "specialness" of Vincent isn't really a major plot point, so it doesn't matter much where you get your information. So never mind.)

    ReplyDelete
  42. The mobisode is what gives me pause in the whole "Christian is an agent of Jacob's nemesis" thing. Why, if he was talking to a dog, would he need to call Jack "my son?" Why would Christian and Locke be manifested at the same time? Why is there no body, like there is with Locke? No, unlike Locke, I think Christian Shepherd is genuinely reanimated, though I have no idea why. Yet.

    ReplyDelete
  43. Frowny: Christian may of been reanimated by Jacob (Not Jacob's Nemesis) and in a different way?
    His body might of fallen into sea (I cannot remember if the coffin was open or not =/)

    But those two things are highly unlikely. Christian is an interesting & confusing subject. One of the biggest mysterious.

    ReplyDelete
  44. I always thought that the scene where kate takes the shoes off the dead body was supposed to be a reference to the wizard of oz. dorothy takes the ruby slippers off a pair of legs sticking out from under a house before leaving the relative safety of munchkinland to venture into the unknown land of oz just as kate removes the hiking boots off a pair of legs sticking out from under airplane wreckage before venturing from the relative safety of the beach into the unknown depths of the jungle. although technically dorothy doesn't remove her slippers physically, but has them magically transported onto her feet by glinda. still the image of feet sticking out is the same.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Yes, and also the guy in the suit and red sneakers that desmond and eloise see crushed by scaffolding (although only a visual motif in that scene)

    sayid'sgirl:
    a lot of people are talking about the differences in jack's count to five story as evidence that he's lying to try to make himself look better or whatever. it's far more simple than that: he's trying to help kate to calm down and focus on the task at hand, by telling an anecdote to illustrate a mental trick that has worked for him in the past. including a whole bunch of unnecessary information about his troubled relationship with his dead father in the anecdote would just be confusing and, well, unnecessary. (there is also a trace of him subconsciously still working through his father issues in the way he tells the story, but this is subconscious, and not evidence that he's a lying fraud, or that there's a new timeline etc.)

    ReplyDelete
  46. I only just noticed that the first two times we see Hurley he's clutching a watch. I wonder what that's about.

    ReplyDelete